Finance & Accounting · Indianapolis, IN

Payroll Specialist jobs in Indianapolis, IN

Payroll specialists make sure people are paid correctly and on time. They process pay runs, handle deductions, and keep payroll compliant with federal, state, and local requirements.

167
Open roles today
$20–$40/hr
Typical pay range
$59k
Median, full-time
7
Fresh in this list

No email, no resume, no sign-up. Save any listing below and you start anonymously.

You're signed in. Saving a listing drops it straight into your pipeline.

01

Open payroll specialist roles

12 shown of 167 · sorted by freshness

Night Audit (Overnight Desk Clerk)

Comfort Suites Southport · Indianapolis, IN · Part-time

No matter whether a guest arrives weary from their travels or excited for a vacation, as a Night Auditor, you know what to do to make them feel at home. They will appreciate the pristine lobby, your warm welcome, and you…

Posted 2d ago
+ Save to tracker View listing

Payroll Manager

Ivy Hospitality - Corporate Office · Indianapolis, IN · Full-time
$65k - $75k

Position Summary: The Payroll Manager is responsible for overseeing all aspects of payroll processing and administration. The Payroll Manager’s primary focus will be to ensure accurate and timely payroll operations while…

Posted 2d ago
+ Save to tracker View listing

Billing Specialist

Tegna · Indianapolis, IN · Full-time

local news. TEGNA one of the most geographically diverse broadcasters in the U.S. is seeking a Billing/Log Reconciliation Specialist to join our Shared Services team. This position will be part of the TEGNA corporate tea…

Posted 2d ago
+ Save to tracker View listing

Billing Specialist

CFS · Indianapolis, IN · Full-time
$32 per hour

Job Title: Billing Specialist Location: Indianapolis, IN [MUST LIVE IN INDIANA] Fully in OfficePay Rate: $32-34 hourly About Us: Our client a leading construction company with a commitment to excellence and a track recor…

Posted 2d ago
+ Save to tracker View listing

Payroll Specialist

CFS · Indianapolis, IN · Full-time
$50k

Payroll AdministratorSalary: $50,000 - $70,000Location: Carmel, INSchedule: HybridWhy This Opportunity Stands Out:• Join a mission-driven organization with a strong sense of purpose and impact across Indiana• Collaborati…

Posted 3d ago
+ Save to tracker View listing

Payroll Applications Coordinator

All Positions · Greenwood, IN · Full-time

Full Time Day Shift 8:00am-5:00pm Monday-Friday The Coordinator Payroll Applications is responsible for multi-company web-based payrolls overseeing payroll staff and resolving complex payroll issues. Maintains advanced k…

Posted 6d ago
+ Save to tracker View listing

Legal Billing Coordinator

Liberty Personnel Services, Inc. · Indianapolis, IN

****@*****.*** Please add me on LinkedIn! Matt Naumenko, Liberty Personnel Services ****@*****.*** Experience Associate Employment type Permanent Job function Billing Specialist #Libertyjobs #Legal #Billing #E-Billing...

Posted 1w ago
+ Save to tracker View listing

Payroll Specialist

Managepoint · Indianapolis, IN · Full-time
$24.04 - $28.85 per hour

Indianapolis, IN (Northside, 100% On-site)Job Type: Full-time, PermanentJob SummaryWe are seeking an experienced, fast paced HRO Payroll Specialist to join our team in Indianapolis. In this Human Resources Outsourcing (H…

Posted 2w ago
+ Save to tracker View listing

Billing Admin

AMR ROOFING · Indianapolis, IN · Full-time
$40k - $55k

Billing Admin – AMR ROOFING Overview The Account Billing Manager is responsible for overseeing the full billing cycle at AMR Roofing, ensuring that invoices, insurance claims, supplements, client payments, and subcontrac…

Posted 2w ago
+ Save to tracker View listing

Payroll Accounting Specialist

TMA Small Business Accounting PC · Indianapolis, IN · Full-time
$24 - $32 per hour

Payroll Accounting SpecialistProfessional payroll work for small business clients - with paid certification and a clear path to grow... ...OverviewReporting to the Director of Payroll Services, the Payroll Accounting Spe…

Posted 1mo ago
+ Save to tracker View listing

Sr. Billing Specialist

Ogletree Deakins · Indianapolis, IN · Full-time

Position Summary: Join our dynamic Corporate Accounting and Finance Team at Ogletree Deakins as a Sr. Billing Specialist to support our Indianapolis, IN office. This role is pivotal in supporting and enhancing our firm's…

Posted 1mo ago
+ Save to tracker View listing
02

What payroll specialists earn in Indianapolis

Hourly first — that's how the offer arrives

ExperienceHourlyAnnual, full-time
Entry level $20–$26 $42k–$54k
Mid level $25–$32 $51k–$67k
Senior $31–$40 $65k–$84k

Adjusted for the Indianapolis market from national ranges.

03

What employers ask for

The skills these listings keep naming

Payroll processingADP, Paychex, or WorkdayMulti-state payroll taxWage and hour complianceGarnishments and deductionsBenefits administration basicsExcelDiscretion and confidentialityAccuracy under deadlines
04

Interview questions worth rehearsing

With the thing the interviewer is actually listening for

Walk me through a full payroll cycle you have run.

Cover collecting time data, validating changes, processing, review, and post-run reporting. Emphasize your checks before anything is finalized.

How do you handle a payroll error after employees have been paid?

Show urgency and correctness: quantify the error, follow the legal rules for corrections, communicate honestly with those affected, and fix the root cause.

What experience do you have with multi-state payroll?

Name the states and the wrinkles you managed, such as local taxes, differing overtime rules, or remote-worker registrations.

How do you process garnishments and other involuntary deductions?

Show you know the order of priority, response deadlines, and the documentation trail, and that you treat these with strict confidentiality.

Which payroll systems have you used, and have you been through a conversion?

Name the platforms and your depth in each. Conversion or implementation experience is a strong differentiator worth detailing.

How do you keep payroll data confidential?

Mention access controls, clean-desk habits, and declining to discuss compensation outside proper channels, even under social pressure.

05

Resume tips that move the needle

For payroll specialists specifically — generic advice costs you here

01

State the payroll size you ran: employee count, pay frequencies, and number of states or entities.

02

Quantify accuracy, such as error rates or consecutive on-time pay runs, since that is the core promise of the role.

03

Name your platforms exactly — ADP Workforce Now, Paychex Flex, Workday, Gusto — as job posts filter on them.

04

Include compliance wins, like clean payroll tax filings, resolved agency notices, or year-end W-2 cycles delivered without corrections.

05

List certifications such as FPC or CPP; they carry real weight in payroll hiring.

06

Where this role goes

Typical progression

01 Payroll Clerk
02 Payroll Specialist
03 Senior Payroll Specialist
04 Payroll Manager
Ten quiet minutes a day

Applying for payroll specialist jobs in Indianapolis?

Robbi carries this page into your first day: your role, your city, your shift preference. Then it hands you a few small things each morning and keeps the pipeline honest.

Save what looks right here, then let Robbi hand you a few small things each morning and keep the follow-ups honest.

Start with this search No email, no resume, no sign-up. Open your tracker Everything you saved is already there.
167 Payroll Specialist roles in Indianapolis Save them into one pipeline Save them into your pipeline
Start free My tracker